?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Aaaaand we have our first overlap with the AFI project. There's only gonna be a handful of those. So we've established that its a damn good movie, and that I love it oh so much.

When I was watching it that time, the roomie walks by. "You're watching Shawshank Redemption?" "Yeah" "I respect you". She then grabs a snack and sits on the couch.

Important thing that's different for me since the last viewing--I read the Stephen King novella a couple weeks ago. Its in the same book as Apt Pupil (which I mentioned in passing earlie today). The adaptation is incredibly true to the story. I suppose its always easier to do that with shorter stories than with big huge novels.

I loved reading the description of Andy's character in the book. Robbins played him perfectly, but there's just something so powerful about reading the descriptions.

The movie added some nice touches I rather like:
-When Andy asks Red for Rita Hayworth, the film plays it like he's jokingly asking for the actress. The book makes it more clear that he wants a poster. That is later used to show how far back he'd been planning his escape. Ooops, spoiler. Sorry, I assume most of you have seen it.
-The bit with the music over the loudspeakers isnt in the book
-Tommy is bribed in the book. The way his situation was handled in the film is much more effective.
-The film develops the secondary characters a lot more. The book really just focuses on Red and Andy.
-Ha! Love the "maybe because Im Irish" bit. He really is Irish in the novella. Just one of many times Morgan Freeman transcends race in a killer performance!
-The film flows a bit better. The roof thing leads into the bookkeeping thing. The book was a bit more mismatched.

I guess I should have said earlier that in general I tend to prefer watching the movie then reading the book. That way Im not reading for plot, Im reading for details. I dont rush thru the ending to find out what's gonna happen. And Im discovering new scenes instead of being disappointed that they werent on screen.

Its actually a bit tough to pick apart differences because I know the film so well and read the book so recently. But there really weren't many at all. Its as faithful an adaptation as Green Mile was.
Expletive Dleted    ExpDelTop100     AFI Project    Mini Projects     The Movie Wall Of Doom     All Write Ups
   Twitter   Facebook